After reading the title of this post you may be thinking, "Chili and cornbread? Soup? Turkey and dressing? Pumpkin muffins?" You would be wrong with all those guesses! My most recent Fall favorite flavors are in the form of ice cream. It was in the upper 90s last week, so ice cream was exactly what I wanted.
I'm kind of obsessed with making a gallon of vanilla ice cream, then dividing it up in four quarts with four unique flavors. This time I made Caramel Apple, Chocolate-Hot Tamale, Pumpkin, and Snickerdoodle.
I made a few changes this time and I think it turned out better than ever. I started with my Old Fashioned Vanilla Ice Cream recipe. Once the ice cream finished churning, I divided it into my four quart size containers. Instead of adding my flavors, I put the quarts in the freezer for about an hour. I then pulled one quart out at a time and poured the ice cream into a larger bowl for mixing. This allowed the ice cream to firm up a little more so when I added in the additional flavors they would not sink to the bottom of the container. This worked like a charm! Now on to the flavors...
Caramel Apple
1 Granny Smith apple, peeled and chopped
1/2 cup Kraft Caramel Bits
This was close to what I wanted. The apple pieces were tart but the caramel bits got a little too hard after freezing. I think I could have got the same flavor by adding caramel syrup instead. Still, it was really good. I'd say a 7 out of 10.
Chocolate-Hot Tamale
1/2 cup Hot Tamales, chopped
1/2 piece chocolate cake, chopped.
Last year Baskin Robbins carried a flavor called "Spicy 'n Spooky." This was White Chocolate Ghost Pepper flavored Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Ice Cream and spicy Blood Orange Flakes and had quite the kick! I tried to come up with something similar. The Hot Tamales froze too hard like the caramel bits, but the flavor was good. I'd call this a 6.5 out of 10.
Pumpkin
1 dozen Pumpkin Spice cookies, crushed.
The pumpkin spice cookie mix said that it would make 15 cookies. They would have been very large cookies. I made normal size cookies. My first pan had a dozen and my second pan was a little larger and I was able to get another 20 cookies. I cooked the pan that I wanted to use in my ice cream longer than normal, I wanted the cookies crunchy instead of soft and chewy like I usually make. This one was exactly what I was looking for! Definitely a 10 out of 10.
Snickerdoodle
Approximately 1/2 tube of sugar cookie dough
1/2 cup cinnamon/sugar mix
I bought a tube of "safe to eat raw" cookie dough. I have been eating raw cookie dough for over 50 years so I'm sure I could have made this with "not safe to eat raw" dough, too. I made small balls with the dough, then put them in the freezer until I was ready to add to the ice cream. I mixed it with the cinnamon/sugar and dumped it all in the ice cream so there was a taste of cinnamon throughout. This was another winner! 10 out of 10.


































